You do have the option of taking private and if the model has a fan club they can give you free membership just so you can whisper to them.

NO, that's exactly wrong!
Taking a model private does not solve the issue. First of all, whispering is disabled during privates too, which exposes me to a huge privacy risk. Another user in this thread described a situation in which chat conversations during a private show leaked to the other users.
Beside that, many of us – both models and users – wish to be able to communicate discretely outside private shows too. The barrier is way too high to even start a private if you cannot even begin with loose smalltalk – at least without being put on the spot like this cause the whole room can see what you're typing. That's not my understanding of spending a nice evening in an inviting atmosphere.
Regarding fanclubs, that whole thing is just not leading anywhere if the model doesn't have (or wanna have) a fanclub. But even if she has a fan club, why make it so complicated? I don't get the whole argument of many people here in favor of this change in the first place: at first, they are happy that whispering is disabled, stating this way it helps bringing people together, then they happily defend possibilities to bypass that, like fanclubs or VIP, asking: where's the problem? To which I answer: why make it more difficult and expensive as it would have to be?
Quote